I disagree entirely.
I dont vote to get commans like /ioncannon
The commands have no value, no benafit, they're for fun. I vote for kreatious.
Consider these 2 servers:
Server 1: 15 active players per day. Each player spends 90% of their time spent on minecraft on this server, it is their favourite. Server 1 has a heavy voting reward system meaning that each of these 15 players votes each day. Additionally, each member that signs up to the server and does not return in the future is likely to vote in order to get the reward (free diamonds for example), even if they do not like the server yet.
Due to it only being a small server, this leads to maybe 5 new sign ups per day, totalling 20 votes per day.
Server 2: 50 active players per day. Each player spends 90% of their time spent on minecraft on this server, it is their favourite. Server 2 has a very mild voting reward system meaning that only around 35% of players votes each day despite it being their main server.
New members are unlikely to vote as there is no reward in doing so and they have not decided if they like the server yet.
For arguments sake, this server also receives 5 new sign ups per day.
This totals 17 votes per day (rounded down).
While Server 1 is over-rated by its 100% voters idea, server 2 is under rated (statistically) because of the lack of incentives.
Minestatus’ ranking system works in such a way that number of active voting players = quality of server.
Meaning that a server with more players is higher up, which honestly is a good reflection upon the servers quality (better servers retain players to a greater extent). We have good player retention and an active player base, but a lack of voters.
The benefit of the proposed system of limiting commands such as /go /home /spawn is that the block does not apply to newbies, we would not be forcing each sign up to vote - a kind of "try before you buy" approach to voting.
All we would be asking is that the players who come to the server regularly assist our minestatus rank to reflect that. We should not be stuck behind servers with 15 active members.Other proposals such as voting tied in to becoming and staying a resident support a similar idea - If you want to be a resident, you have to be willing to tell people (anonomously) that you are one.